Thursday, December 12, 2013

News articles and links from December 12, 2013


Bay Delta Conservation Plan

From: Dan Masnada, Santa Clarita Valley Signal

Build it once. Build it right.

That approach can be applied to many things. If you were building a house from scratch, what would serve you better - cutting corners on design, construction techniques and materials or building a well-designed home meant to last?

Is the cheaper house better if you have to rebuild it in a few years or if you have to add on because your design wasn't large enough to accommodate your family?

From: Staff, Fresno Bee

The drought is devastating San Joaquin Valley farms and leaving parched growers with no choice but to drill ever deeper for water. Tapping the aquifer for more water, we know, isn't sustainable. Nor is it good for the environment.

In the face of likely catastrophe, Gov. Jerry Brown and President Barack Obama should act on the requests of California lawmakers - both in Sacramento and Washington, D.C. - and declare a state of emergency.

From: Staff, Sacramento Bee

Despite the state's 34,000-page draft environmental impact study, fundamental questions remain unanswered about the proposal to build two huge tunnels to divert water from the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta to points south.

The basic financial framework, for example, remains unresolved. Yet to be determined is how the multibillion-dollar cost would be split among water agencies who would benefit, and the state and federal governments. What would be the role be of the Delta counties? The report also fails to define what future water flows would be through the Delta.

Water Supply 

From: Tom Nassif, Fresno Bee

A federal report last week called attention to land subsidence in the San Joaquin Valley as a result of excessive pumping of groundwater. It is true that groundwater is being used to irrigate farms at an unsustainable rate. It is also true that something needs to change.

However, the prevailing and one-sided commentary from government officials and environmental organizations can be summed up as, "Farmers should use less water." No one outside of the farm communities that produce healthy and affordable food for our entire nation seems willing to look at another obvious answer: The federal and state governments need to restore reliable surface water deliveries to our farms.

From: Kurtis Alexander, SFgate.com

After an unusually dry start to the rainy season, two California lawmakers are urging Gov. Jerry Brown to declare a drought emergency.

Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein and Rep. Jim Costa, D-Fresno, sent a letter to the governor's office this week, saying the state is facing a third consecutive year of scant rainfall that could deplete reservoirs and leave farmers without enough water to grow their crops.

Water Storage


On a summer day in 1962, President John F. Kennedy helicoptered into the hot, dusty grasslands between Gilroy and Los Banos and pushed a dynamite plunger in a ceremony with California Gov. Pat Brown.

"It is a pleasure for me to come out here and help blow up this valley for the cause of progress," Kennedy told the cheering throngs who had come to see the president launch construction of the San Luis Reservoir.

Wednesday, December 11, 2013

News articles and links from December 11, 2013


Bay Delta Conservation Plan

From: Roger Dickinson, Sacramento Bee

For two decades, Sacramento battled with the East Bay Municipal Utility District over diverting water from the American River, which would have reduced our water flows, endangered fish and other wildlife, degraded the American River Parkway and compromised our water rights. After battling to a standstill for several years, my colleagues on the Sacramento City Council and county Board of Supervisors, Sen. Dianne Feinstein and I worked out a solution with EBMUD that met the critical needs and objectives of both sides.

Coalition response... Notwithstanding Assemblyman Dickinson's take on the issue, the Bay Delta Conservation Plan has been one of the most transparent planning processes in history. There has been ongoing and focused outreach by administration officials to Delta counties, including regular meetings with Secretary Laird and other high-ranking officials. Claiming that public water agencies south of the Delta are going to run the project without limits simply ignores reality and is irresponsible hyperbole. It has been disproved every day for the past 20 years as the State and federal projects operate to the water quality, environmental and water rights standards set by the SWRCB and a host of other state and federal agencies. The BDCP will also be governed by permits issued by the SWRCB, which will satisfy the stringent conditions imposed by state and federal fishery agencies.  The BDCP must satisfy the highest environmental standards in the nation to be approved and implemented.

It has taken seven years of intense research and planning to craft a solution that addresses both water supply issues and environmental needs. Now that a public review draft has been released let's give it the consideration due.  A plan designed to resolve these long-term challenges for our state deserves deliberate, reasonable review.

From: Mary Leo, Sacramento Bee

Re "Delta details unveiled - in 34,000 pages" (Page A1, Dec. 10): Please, who has time to read 34,000 pages in a year? I doubt any of our elected officials who will vote on this proposal involving two giant water-diversion tunnels will accomplish this task. How can we expect a fair and unbiased outcome to this proposal if the average person cannot read the details in the time allotted to be fully informed on this matter?

Coalition response...
Mary,

The BDCP documents ARE complex- but they have to be. These 34,000 pages include plans to improve the delta ecosystem while providing a more stable supply of water to Californians south of the Delta. Environmental Impact Reports must be thorough and consequently are often long documents. The administrators of the Bay Delta Conservation Plan are actively looking to facilitate reviewers through twitter. If you're looking for specific content in the plan, tweet your question, including the hashtag #WhereinBDCP.

Bay Delta Conservation Plan

From: Charles Wilson and Mike Wade, Los Angeles Daily News

Southern Californians are leaders in conservation, using the same amount of water today as 20 years ago, despite adding 3 million people to the population. The region has recycled more water than anywhere else in the United States and invested more than $5 billion in storage facilities to improve local water supply reliability. This way of life has become essential as we have faced droughts and reduced imported water supplies. But cities aren't alone in learning how to be more efficient with water.

From: David Benda, Redding Record-Searchlight

An environmental disaster that will bankrupt taxpayers is the initial response of some local stakeholders to Monday's release of a huge state water plan.

The Bay Delta Conservation Plan is billed as a long-term strategy for the management and development of water resources in the face of an uncertain future for California.

From: Staff, Redding Record-Searchlight

Does anyone really understand the Bay Delta Conservation Plan?

Yes, we know the plan that the state formally released this week involves restoring habitat in the delta down where the Sacramento River meets the bay, along with a pair of tunnels proponents hope will work more reliably and less destructively than the long-running system of pumping North State water through the delta itself.

Water Plan 

From: Steve Knell, Merced Sun-Star
From: Steve Knell, Modesto Bee

The Brown administration recently released a draft California Water Action Plan, the purpose of which is to outline and address the state's water challenges and provide sustainable management goals for our water resources. The action plan includes a suite of recommendations that, if implemented, would provide sound water policy guidance.

Unfortunately, there are those in Sacramento whose agenda differs from that of the governor.

Water Supply

From: Staff, KTVU.com
From: AP Staff, Sacramento Bee

With another dry winter looming, California lawmakers called on Gov. Jerry Brown and President Barack Obama to declare a drought emergency and federal disaster in the state.

In a letter sent Monday, Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein and Democratic Rep. Jim Costa urged the governor to take immediate action. A separate letter signed by dozens of other California lawmakers called for the same declaration.

The lawmakers cited the California Department of Water Resources' announcement of low water deliveries for Central Valley agriculture due to light rainfall projections.

Transfers

From: Antoine Abou-Diwan, Imperial Valley Press

The Metropolitan Water District of Southern California approved an agreement with the Imperial Irrigation District Tuesday that would allow both agencies to share equally in the costs of upgrading earthquake-damaged water infrastructure in Mexico, in return for an equal share of conserved water that should result.

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

News articles and links from December 10, 2013


Bay Delta Conservation Plan

From: Dan Walters, Sacramento Bee
From: Dan Walters, Modesto Bee

Gov. Jerry Brown's administration released two massive documents Monday, detailing its plans to build twin tunnels beneath the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta and complete the last link of the water system his father began more than a half-century ago.

Minutes later, opponents of the Bay Delta Conservation Plan declared that they will use every available legal and political process to kill it.

Coalition response... It is interesting to note that opponents of the plan were condemning it only minutes after the release of the document that took many years worth of scientific research, engineering investigation, and conservation expertise to create. In their haste to maintain the precarious status quo, opponents of the BDCP are willing to sacrifice the opportunity to provide reliable water supplies while improving the sustainability of the Bay-Delta.

From: Andrew Creasey, Marysville Appeal-Democrat

Local elected officials and legislators unanimously disapprove of the Bay Delta Conservation Plan and its proposal to construct two massive tunnels to divert water from the north toward the south.

The public draft of the Bay Delta Conservation Plan and environmental impacts reports and statements were released on Monday - about 34,000 pages of studies seven years in the making.

Coalition response... The California Farm Water Coalition is a statewide organization with members from Redding to the Imperial Valley. While many Northern Californians believe that the BDCP will be harmful to the region, ecosystem improvements in the Delta will help improve the survivability of salmon that return to the Sacramento River and its tributaries to spawn. Fixing long-standing problems in the Delta will have benefits for Northern California fisheries while modernizing and improving the efficiency of our aging infrastructure.

Bay Delta Conservation Plan

From: Paul Rogers, San Jose Mercury News  
From: Paul Rogers, Contra Costa Times  

Ever since he took office three years ago, Gov. Jerry Brown has been trying to build two landmark public works projects to reshape California: a $68 billion high-speed rail system and a $25 billion overhaul of the state's water system, including two massive tunnels under the Delta.

Both have been debated separately so far, with most public attention going to the bullet train plan.

From: Heather Hacking, Chico Enterprise-Record

The environmental reports for plans for the Bay Delta Conservation Plan were released Monday, beginning a new flurry of debate.

The $24.7 billion plan, seven years in the making, includes Gov. Jerry Brown's proposal for 35 miles of tunnels that would move water under the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, rather than through a system of pumps in the south Delta that are known to harm fish.

From: John Myers, News10.net

Seven years and tens of thousands of pages in the making, state officials have submitted their full proposal for a Delta water system that seeks compromise on what may be California's most long-running and heated battle.

"It's a complicated picture," said Paul Helliker, deputy director of the state Department of Water Resources.

From: Bettina Boxall, L.A. Times

A $25-billion proposal to re-engineer the hub of California's sprawling water system may not yield all the water that San Joaquin Valley farmers and Southland cities want, leaving open the question of whether the massive project will be built.

The delivery estimates are included in draft plans and environmental impact documents released Monday. Totaling more than 30,000 pages, the drafts underscore the many uncertainties about a project that has been in the planning stages for years and is a centerpiece of Gov. Jerry Brown's water policy.

From: Melody Gutierrez, San Francisco Chronicle

After seven years in the making, the $25 billion plan to build two massive tunnels diverting water out of the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta is up for public review. And one thing is clear: You better grab your reading glasses.

From: Matt Weiser, Fresno Bee  
From: Matt Weiser, Sacramento Bee

A new future for the troubled Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta was laid out for public review Monday in 34,000 pages of analysis associated with two giant water diversion tunnels proposed by Gov. Jerry Brown. The question now for the public and policy makers: Is this the future they want?


California water officials have released a draft copy of a $24.7 billion plan to restore the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, in part by building two 30-mile tunnels to ensure stable water delivery to millions of Californians.

The joint federal and state Bay Delta Conservation Plan and environmental impact analysis released Monday includes plans for building the tunnels and completing significant habitat restoration work to improve the delivery of mountain snowmelt to Central Valley farms and cities throughout the state.

From: Jason Dearen, SFgate.com

California water officials on Monday released a draft of a $24.7 billion plan to restore the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, in part by building two 30-mile underground tunnels to ensure stable water delivery to millions of Californians.

The joint federal and state Bay Delta Conservation Plan, or BDCP, and environmental impact analysis comes after seven years of study, and includes plans for building the tunnels and completing significant habitat restoration work to improve the delivery of mountain snowmelt to Central Valley farms and cities throughout the state.

At the heart of the 50-year plan unveiled last summer by Gov. Jerry Brown are the twin tunnels with a 9,000-cubic-feet-per-second capacity that would replace the delta's current pumping system that endangers fish and other wildlife.

From: Jim Carlton, Wall Street Journal (subscription required)

A contentious project to divert water supplied to Southern California past an ecologically sensitive river delta moved a step closer to fruition Monday, as state and federal officials unveiled a draft final environmental analysis.

Under the $25 billion plan, which is backed by Gov. Jerry Brown, two 30-mile-long tunnels would bypass the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta in Northern California. The area often serves as a choke point for water destined for more than 20 million people and farmland in semiarid parts of Southern California and the Central Valley because of pumping restrictions to protect endangered smelt and other fish.

From: Lauren Sommer, KQED Science Blog

Seven years in the making, state officials on Monday unveiled the latest version of their ambitious plan for revitalizing the heart of California's embattled water system and securing supplies for decades to come.

The Bay Delta Conservation Plan and its environmental review weigh in at 34,000 pages - that's before public comments start pouring in next week for a 120-day feedback period.

From: Staff, State Water Contractors

Note: A summary of public statements and comments on the BDCP compiled by the State Water Contractors.

From: CTRS Staff, News10.net

Monday, a statewide coalition and a few lawmakers presented a united front against Gov. Brown's proposed tunnel water project. Their protest comes as the EPA just released environmental impact documents on the nearly $25 billion project.

The proposal calls for building tunnels to divert water from the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta to the Central Valley to benefit farmers. It's called the Bay Delta Conservation Plan, but opponents say the project could threaten habitats for wildlife such as fish populations and sandhill cranes which rely on the water from the delta to thrive.

Levees

From: Dennis Taylor, The Salinas Californian

With rain on the horizon, growers in the Salinas Valley are hoping for two things: A wet winter and a not-so-wet winter.

With regulators having put the kibosh on allowing farmers to cut trees and brush and remove debris and sediment, the Salinas River channel is estimated to accommodate only half the water volume of recent years, a situation farmers underscore by recalling the disastrous flood of 1995.

Monday, December 9, 2013

News articles and links from December 9, 2013


Bay Delta Conservation Plan

From: Alex Breitler, Stockton Record

Somewhere in her rural home on Roberts Island, Delta activist Rogene Reynolds keeps a storage bin filled with mementoes from decades past.

But they're not cherished family photos or letters.

Reynolds' keepsakes include dog-eared reports by water wonks who have long since retired, and maps of California's immense water distribution system.

Coalition response... What should stun reporters and the public is that opponents of the Bay Delta Conservation Plan have been able to get away with distributing misleading information about California's water supply, water rights and the goal of the proposed twin tunnels. Why does Tom Zuckerman keep telling people that the BDCP doesn't produce any new water? Because he knows that most people don't realize that the project is simply trying to restore the delivery of water to people south of the Delta that they already have a legal right to use. No one is "stealing the water" and he knows it.

Fisheries

From: Peter Moyle, California Water Blog

The primary goal of the federal Endangered Species Act (ESA) is to shorten the government's list of "endangered" and "threatened" species. The American Peregrine falcon, the brown pelican, the eastern Steller sea lion and California populations of the gray whale are among the iconic creatures that have recovered to large populations and have been "delisted," thanks to the strong conservation measures afforded under the 40-year-old law.

But there is another, less congratulatory way species have made it off the lists: new and better information becomes available showing a species is no longer or never was in danger of extinction.

Salton Sea

From: Tony Perry, L.A. Times

With an ominous deadline approaching, two feuding Imperial Valley agencies have put aside their differences and developed a plan they hope can save the ailing Salton Sea, the state's largest body of water and often considered its most vexing environmental problem.

The Imperial Irrigation District and the Imperial County Board of Supervisors have agreed to push for additional geothermal energy exploration on the eastern edge of the sea.

Reservoirs

From: Thaddeus Miller, Merced Sun-Star  
From: J.N. Sbranti, Modesto Bee

Water levels appear frighteningly low at the San Luis Reservoir, but water officials assure that is relatively normal this time of year.

In fact, government researchers have just completed a study about expanding the reservoir, which they say would increase California's water storage capacity and improve the reliability of water supplied by Central Valley Project canals.

Water Supply

From: Staff, Redding Record-Searchlight

Last week's water-bond hearing brought a much-needed political focus on the link between up-country forests and the water supplies of those downstream - but even Assemblyman Brian Dahle, who'll grab any opportunity to push the issue, doesn't really think a state bond is the way to pay to thin and tend forests.

So what's the better way? How about we bill the people using the water for the work needed to restore watersheds? Get Angelenos to pay for maintain the North State forests that are the source of their clean water.

Bay Delta Conservation Plan

From: Matt Weiser, Sacramento Bee

The giant Delta water-diversion tunnels proposed by Gov. Jerry Brown need $1.2 billion more spent on planning and design before construction starts or is even assured.

The additional planning costs, which come on top of $240 million already spent, first came to light at a board meeting of the Westlands Water District late last month. The Sacramento Bee confirmed this additional planning cost in recent interviews with the California Department of Water Resources, which is leading the project, and several of the water agencies that are responsible for the bills.

From: Mark Gold, L.A. Observed

Mark the calendar. This week will go down as a crucial week in California's water history. The draft Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) and associated Environmental Impact Report/Environmental Impact Statement (EIR/EIS) was filed with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency on Friday and the public comment period begins this week. So if you're in the mood for reading over 10,000 pages on the state's attempt to fix the Delta of the Sacramento and San Joaquin Rivers and provide farmers and urban users--including Angelenos--with a more reliable water supply for the future, happy holidays to you!

From: Tib Belza, NCWA Blog

With the state and federal agencies releasing the Bay-Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) this week, the leaders in the North State are unified in our commitment to statewide water solutions that protect the economy, environment and quality of life in Northern California. The North State Water Alliance this week continues our call for the Governor to develop an innovative and comprehensive statewide water plan. This plan must not exclusively focus on new infrastructure in the Bay-Delta and related restoration actions, however much as those elements may be needed, but must also meet the Legislature's overarching goal of providing a more reliable water supply for all of California.

From: Amy Quinton, Capital Public Radio

The BDCP proposes to restore the ecology of the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta and build two tunnels to carry water from the Delta to central and southern California.

The release of what's called the Environmental Impact Report is one of the biggest steps in what's been a multi-year planning process.

It marks the beginning of the formal public review of the plan.