Showing posts with label Delta Protection Commission. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Delta Protection Commission. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 14, 2013

News articles and links from August 14, 2013


Bay Delta Conservation Plan 

From: Chris Acree, Fresno Bee

At the Aug. 3 Delta Water Summit held at Fresno State, I was disappointed to see little attention paid to the basic science and economics of the $48 billion twin-tunnels proposal. The tunnels will not add one drop of new water to the state's water supply. So who will benefit from the project and who has to pay for it?

Coalition response...This letter-writer may want to update his information before writing again about the Bay Delta Conservation Plan and its proposed tunnels. A full economic impacts study has been conducted by The Brattle Group, coordinated by Dr. David Sunding, Thomas J. Graff Chair in Natural Resource Economics at U.C. Berkeley. Sunding is also the founder of Berkeley Water Center and his clients include the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission and U.S. Department of Justice. He is currently providing expert testimony in two interstate water disputes before the U.S. Supreme Court. His credentials are impeccable.

According to Dr. Sunding, the statewide benefit to California from implementing the BDCP is an $84 billion increase in business activity, $11 billion in wages for California workers and 1.1 million jobs over the 50-year BDCP lifespan. These economic benefits should be embraced by everyone struggling in this current economy. Read the study at: http://baydeltaconservationplan.com/Libraries/Dynamic_Document_Library/Draft_BDCP_Statewide_Economic_Impact_Report_8-5-13.sflb.ashx.

Trinity River 

From: Farmwater

United States District Judge Lawrence J. O'Neill issued a temporary restraining order halting water releases from Trinity Reservoir by the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation through Friday, August 16. According to the Order, the stated purpose of the planned releases is to "reduce the likelihood, and potentially reduce the severity, of any Ich epizootic event that could lead to associated fish die off in 2013" in the lower Klamath River.

The full order by Judge O'Neill is available here.

From: Damon Arthur, Redding Record Searchlight

At the request of San Joaquin Valley farmers, a federal judge in Fresno today ordered a halt to higher water releases in the Trinity River designed to keep Chinook salmon from becoming diseased and dying.

The U.S. Bureau of Reclamation already had started ramping up releases from Lewiston Dam today from 450 cubic-feet per second to 750 CFS before the judge called a halt to the project, forcing the bureau to begin dialing back flows.

From: Mark Grossi, Fresno Bee
From: Mark Grossi, Modesto Bee
From: Mark Grossi, Merced Sun-Star

A U.S. District Court in Fresno has stopped the release of Trinity River water to protect salmon in Northern California until Friday.

From: Kimberly Wear, Eureka Times-Standard  

A U.S. District Court judge in Fresno halted water releases meant to prevent a fish kill on the lower Klamath River on Tuesday, granting a temporary restraining order sought by farmers in the San Joaquin Valley who filed a lawsuit against the federal government last week.

From: Bob Egelko, SF Chronicle

Central Valley farmers protesting the federal government's release of water into the Klamath River to protect spawning salmon won a delay of at least three days Tuesday from a federal judge.

From: Associated Press, San Jose Mercury News

A federal judge has temporarily halted plans to release water from the Trinity River to protect Northern California salmon.

From: Staff, Kronick Moskovitz Tiedemann & Girard

On August 13, 2013, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California issued a temporary restraining order ("TRO") prohibiting the Bureau of Reclamation ("Reclamation") from releasing into the Trinity River up to 109,000 acre-feet of water from storage in the federal Central Valley Project's ("CVP") Trinity and Lewiston reservoirs between August 13 and September 30, 2013.

From: Elizabeth Warmerdam, Courthouse News Service

A federal judge Tuesday blocked the planned release of hundreds of millions of gallons of water from the Trinity Reservoir, after water districts sued Uncle Sam, claiming it was putting fish before people.

Water Supply

From: Staff, Porterville Recorder

In Porterville, the past winter season was the driest ever. In other parts of the Valley, it was the sixth-driest since records began to be kept more than 100 years ago.

From: Phil Larson, Public CEO

(This article was previously printed in the Fresno Bee.)
This year Fresno County was able to balance its budget while restoring programs and positions. After years of tough budgets and painful decisions, I wish I could say it was a relief, but instead I am fearful of what could happen next year.

Water Bond

From: Barry Eberling, Fairfield Daily Republic  

State Sen. Lois Wolk has proposed a $5.6 billion state water bond, one that includes no money for the controversial proposal to build twin tunnels to take water exports under the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta.

From: Staff, Woodland Daily Democrat  
Senator Lois Wolk Tuesday introduced a $5.6 billion water bond to provide funding for broadly supported projects to address the state's urgent water needs.

From: Staff, Davis Enterprise

State Sen. Lois Wolk, D-Davis, introduced a $5.6 billion water bond Tuesday to provide funding for projects to address the state's water needs.

Levees

From: Press Release, State Water Contractors

The State Water Contractors is continuing its series of fact sheets analyzing proposed alternatives to the Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) with the release of a fact sheet that reviews the "Fattening" Delta Levees proposal that is suggested by some BDCP opponents. This new analysis explains that while strategic levee improvements are necessary to better protect the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta (Delta), widespread "fattening" of levees alone is not a complete solution for the myriad of problems facing this important estuary.

Bay Delta Conservation Plan

From: Richard Stapler, BDCP  

This summer the Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) is becoming better known and better understood. Thanks to the release of the Administrative Draft of the plan, Californians can view for themselves the scope and purpose.

By the time the Public Draft Plan is released this October and the formal period for gathering public comments begins, the BDCP will be even better. A work in progress, the plan is sure to undergo further modification and strengthening as we respond to people living in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta and state and federal regulatory experts who are providing ongoing environmental reviews.

From: Bryan M. Gold, Elk Grove Citizen

Sacramento County Supervisor Don Nottoli, whose district includes Elk Grove and the Delta, wrote in a magazine article that proceeding with the Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) will change the Delta forever.

From: Pamela Martineau, ACWA

The governance structure and funding sources for the Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) were examined Aug. 13 during a joint informational hearing at the state Capitol of the Senate Governance and Finance Committee and Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee.

From: Maven, Maven's Notebook  

On August 5, the Brown Administration released a draft Statewide Economic Impact Study that estimated that implementation of the Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) would result in positive economic benefits to residents statewide of $4.8 to $5.4 billion.  Some of those benefits include the creation of 177,000 construction and habitat restoration jobs, the avoidance of shortages that could cost 1 million jobs and an increased in statewide economic activity of $84 billion over 50 years, as well as increased recreation opportunities and reduced greenhouse gas emissions, the report says.

Transfers

From: Press Release, USBR  

The Bureau of Reclamation has released for public review draft environmental documents for a Warren Act contract for transfer of up to 15,000 acre-feet of water from Merced Irrigation District to Westlands Water District and/or San Luis Water District.

People

From: Alex Breitler, Stockton Record 

A state agency charged with preserving and protecting the Delta has a new leader.

Erik Vink, a 49-year-old land manager from Yolo County, will replace former state Sen. Michael Machado as the director of the 15-member Delta Protection Commission, according to an announcement Tuesday.

Tuesday, June 25, 2013

News articles and links from June 25, 2013


Delta  

From: Pat Snelling, Vacaville Reporter

The Delta is starving for water, so California officials set up a plan to take more water out of the Delta. How does this make any sense?

California has had a long history of water wars, with many battles and, once again, the state is gearing up for another fight.

The latest "new" Delta plan was released on May 16. Since then, seven lawsuits were filed and probably more are to come.

The Delta Stewardship Council says its plan meets the "co-equal" needs of those depending on Delta water and provides "reliability" for water contractors.

Coalition response...Water in California has generated differing viewpoints throughout our state's history, all the way back to the Gold Rush. Today's discussion focuses on a proposal to provide water to 25 million Californians and almost four thousand farms while restoring the Delta ecosystem, including habitat that will benefit fish species. Pivotal to this discussion are the facts that surround the proposal.

This piece does little to provide factual information on how the Bay Delta Conservation Plan will work for California. The following are some corrections the statements made by Pat Snelling:

Fact #1---The proposed Bay Delta Conservation Plan and its two tunnels are prevented by California law from negatively impacting existing water rights.

Fact #2---Since 2003 San Joaquin Valley farmers have spent more than $2.1 billion upgrading the irrigation systems on more than 1.8 million acres to increase their water use efficiency.

Fact #3---Westlands Water District is a public water agency with a publicly elected board of directors, not a privately owned business. 

Fact #4---More than 50 percent of Westlands farmland grows fresh fruits and vegetables.

Fact #5---The average farm size in Westlands Water District is actually less than 900 acres, not 3,000 as the author claims.

Fact #6---Increased water storage is essential to the future of California and also requires an improved conveyance system through the Delta.

Each Californian should seek the facts regarding water issues confronting our state and not rely on emotion expressed by others.

Bay Delta Conservation Plan 

From: Dennis Wyatt, Manteca Bulletin

The Delta Twin Tunnel plan could rob Manteca of water it has contractually tied up from the Stanislaus River basin.

That's the fear that the Manteca City Council has of the Delta water solution being pursued by Southern California and Bay Area urban water interests as well as large southern San Joaquin Valley farming concerns.

Mayor Willie Weatherford noted construction of the $24.54 billion update of the 1980 Peripheral Canal proposal is being justified by three goals: Saving the Delta, preserving wildlife, and sending more water south.

Coalition response...The concern expressed by Manteca city leaders regarding their water supply is similar to questions raised by others. BDCP officials have repeatedly answered these concerns by stating that the proposed Plan, including the two tunnels, are prevented by California law from negatively impacting existing water rights.

Understanding that the current proposal is not a remake of the 1982 Peripheral Canal is crucial. The current plan offers improvements that did not exist in the canal plan such as the BDCP tunnels will only move 9,000 cubic feet per second of water compared to 21,800 cfs with the Peripheral Canal. Only two fish species, salmon and striped bass, were identified for protection in the canal plan while BDCP includes 214 biological goals and objectives for 57 fish and terrestrial species, their habitat and the Delta ecosystem. Learn more at www.farmwater.org/p-canalcomparison.pdf.

Bay Delta Conservation Plan

From: Mark Truppner, Mother Lode

The State of California and the Obama Administration agreed to a formal deadline of October 1, 2013 for the release of the draft Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) and accompanying environmental documents for public review and comment.

Governor Jerry Brown was Tuesday's KVML "Newsmaker of the Day".

The BDCP will enable the state to make significant progress toward achieving the co-equal goals of securing California's water supply and restoring the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta ecosystem.

Blogs

From: Maven, Maven's Blog

Welcome to Tuesday's blog round-up!  This week's round-up is action packed, so let's get started.

So why did the exporters sue over the Delta Plan?  Alex Breitler says the topic has come up:  "The question came up at yesterday's local Advisory Water Commission meeting: Why did water exporters sue over the Delta Plan? Delta-area folks think they're clearly getting the short shrift; what can the folks down south have to complain about? ... "  Alex ponders the possible reasons on his blog here:  Why did the water exporters sue?   

Yesterday, the State Water Contractors issued their own fact sheet explaining why, giving several reasons, including this:  "While SWC supports how the California Legislature directed the Delta Stewardship Council to create a comprehensive management plan for the Delta, the legislation did not give the Council power to influence or establish future water delivery quantities for public water agencies. However, the Environmental Impact Report for the Delta Plan assumes that its implementation will reduce export levels. Such assumptions are beyond the DSC's legal jurisdiction. This over-reach of legal authority threatens the delicate balance of Delta oversight. Establishing export levels in relation to outflows is a highly-regulated process involving three agencies with state and federal Endangered Species Act jurisdiction as well as the State Water Resources Control Board."  Read the full fact sheet here:  BDCP-Delta Plan Lawsuit SWC Fact Sheet.   

Water Supply

From: KSEE-24 TV

Fresno Irrigation District water deliveries for 2013 will begin coming to an end by the middle of July for the Fancher and Dry Creek Systems as a result of this year's limited water supply. At its June 18 meeting FID's Board of Directors voted to continue deliveries of water through July 31 on the Herndon system.

From: Tim Hearden, Capital Press

The manager of Fresno County's largest farm group says even though the county remained tops in the nation in terms of crop value last year, steeper declines may be on the horizon.

Ryan Jacobsen, the Fresno County Farm Bureau's executive director, said this summer's drought and low water allocations south of the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta forced more land in the valley to be fallowed this year.

From: Tim Hearden, Capital Press

Like Westside melon growers and other California growing operations, table grape producers are feeling the pinch of cutbacks in water allocations.

It's not expected to hurt volumes this year - another record crop is possible since vineyards plan to make up the difference by pumping more groundwater.

But it's a temporary fix.

Fisheries

From: Rebecca M. Quiñones, California WaterBlog

The Klamath River basin presents one of the best opportunities for the reform of hatchery practices and the recovery of wild salmon and trout populations in California.

Much of the habitat for the Klamath's Chinook, coho and steelhead fisheries is in relatively good shape compared with conditions in the Sacramento and San Joaquin river systems. Also, political and legal support for Klamath River restoration is growing.

Invasive Species 

From: Matt Weiser, Sacramento Bee
From: Matt Weiser, Modesto Bee

The State Lands Commission voted Friday to postpone rules that require cargo ships to treat their ballast water before discharging it within California's borders.

Meetings 

From: Water Association of Kern County

Jerry Meral, Deputy Secretary - California Natural Resources Agency
Update on Bay Delta Conservation Plan
July 23, 2013 11:30 a.m.
The Water Association of Kern County Board of Directors and Membership Meeting at the Petroleum Club of Bakersfield, 5060 California Ave., 12th Floor, Bakersfield, CA

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

News articles and links from June 18, 2013


Press Release

From: Chris Knopp, Delta Stewardship Council

Chris Knopp, Executive Officer of the Delta Stewardship Council (DSC), released the following statement regarding the recent lawsuits filed against the DSC seeking a redo of the Council's recently adopted (May 16) comprehensive management plan for the Delta.

Blogs

From: Alex Breitler, eSanJoaquin.com

By my count, seven lawsuits have been filed targeting the recently approved Delta Plan.

Here are all seven complaints. Happy reading.

From: Jay Lund, Californiawaterblog.com

Much of the western and central Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta has sunk deeply below sea level, and it continues to subside as its marsh soils erode from being drained and farmed. At the same time, sea level is rising. The two trends increase these islands' likelihood of flooding from major storms, earthquakes, burrowing rodents and even ship collisions (Lund 2011).

Litigation

From: KTVU.com

Several opposing groups have filed lawsuits against a broad, long-range plan to manage the ailing Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta that was adopted in May.

The four suits, filed over the course of the past month by environmental groups and water users, argue the Delta Plan does not fulfill its two co-equal goals of providing a more reliable water supply for millions of Californians and protecting and restoring the delta ecosystem.

From: The Record Searchlight

Several opposing groups have filed lawsuits against a broad, long-range plan to manage the ailing Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta that was adopted in May.

The four suits, filed over the course of the past month by environmental groups and water users, argue the Delta Plan does not fulfill its two co-equal goals of providing a more reliable water supply for millions of Californians and protecting and restoring the delta ecosystem.

(Coalition Note: Record Searchlight authors include comments from CWIN representative and exclude DSC public statement found in KTVU Story.)

From: KCRA.com, AP
From: News10.net, AP

Environmental and fishing groups have filed a lawsuit against a broad, long-range plan to manage the ailing Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta.

The lawsuit - announced on Monday - is the fourth lawsuit filed against the Delta Plan over the past month.

From: Matt Weiser, Sacramento Bee
From: Matt Weiser, Modesto Bee

A planning document intended to resolve decades of water conflict in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta was instead greeted by a flood of lawsuits on Monday.

At least seven lawsuits were filed in three counties against what is known as the Delta Plan. The plan, which lays out a long-term strategy for developing and managing the sensitive estuary, is required by 2009 state legislation. That law also created the Delta Stewardship Council, a seven-member appointed commission charged with crafting the vision.

From: Matt Weiser, Sacramento Bee

A plan intended, at least in part, to resolve decades of water conflict in the Delta has instead spawned a flood of lawsuits, with at least five separate suits filed against the plan in recent days.

The Delta Plan, as it is known, was required by 2009 state legislation, which also created the Delta Stewardship Council, the organization that adopted the plan on May 16.

Groundwater

From: Jim Johnson, Santa Cruz Sentinel

State water board members received an earful Tuesday of the fierce debate over California American Water's potential right to pump from the overdrafted Salinas Valley groundwater basin for the Monterey Peninsula water project.

During a special meeting at the Monterey Institute of International Studies, the State Water Resources Control Board heard from Salinas Valley growers, their allies and Peninsula interests as part of a public workshop on the water board staff's draft review of the sticky water rights issue.

From: David Sneed, The Tribune

On the surface, the rural parts of San Luis Obispo County north of the Cuesta Grade are a picture of pastoral idyll.

Rolling hills are dotted with country homes - some modest, some palatial - many with horses and other livestock grazing peacefully nearby. Much of the area is also covered with thousands of acres of vineyards.

From: Julie Lynem, The Tribune

With its miles of vineyard-covered hills, Paso Robles is a wine enthusiast's dream and a boon to the local economy. Wine and its related businesses generate thousands of jobs, from the workers who tend the vines to those who design the wine labels, and it has helped spawn a booming tourism industry.

Although the wine industry's growth over the past 30 years has been one of the key economic drivers for San Luis Obispo County, it has come at a high price. The Paso Robles groundwater basin has suffered declining water levels, and that has fueled grave concern about whether there will be enough water to sustain North County residents and businesses - as well as the wine industry.

From: David Sneed, The Tribune

California is one of only two states in the nation that have not comprehensively regulated their groundwater. The other is Texas.

The California Constitution states and courts have upheld the doctrine that landowners whose property overlies an underground aquifer have the right to pump reasonable amounts of water from that aquifer as long as it is put to a beneficial use, such as irrigating crops or supplying drinking water.

Water Bond

From: Richard Lambros, Sacramento Bee

Re "California needs more water storage to end conflicts, bolster its economy" (Viewpoints, June 14): Sen. Dianne Feinstein's call for capturing more water that flows needlessly into the ocean in wet years in preparation for dry years is right on.

Her push for more water storage in advance of parching conditions reinforces what another statesman, Winston Churchill, once said: "Let our advance worrying become advance thinking and planning."

Delta 

From: Jeremy Freitas, Sacramento Bee

It's hypocritical for Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta interests to accuse west side farmers of irrigating lands that should of never been irrigated when the majority of the farmland in the delta exists because of levees that were created by farmers.

The west side has some of the most fertile land in the world, and produces some of the highest yielding crops per acre of any land in California. More storage, more conveyance, an end to discharging partially treated sewage into the delta, and reevaluation of the Endangered Species Act would ensure the recovery of this great state.